The first record of a building on the site dates from 1608, only five years after the end of the Elizabethan era, thanks to a detailed map created by Ralph Treswell, who was commissioned by the Earl of Northumberland. A dwelling and outhouse occupy the site of what is nowThe White Horse Inn

A map of 1746 identifies “a malthouse then commonly called the White Horse, together with woodhouse and garden” in Sutton, and it’s believed brewing had already been underway for some time.

The current building dates to the 18th century and a Tithe Map of 1840 describes a public house “under the sign of the White Horse” with much the same footprint as guests find today. The map shows a cottage at the rear of the pub, converted into ensuite accommodation by the current owners, and a village mostly unchanged to this day.

Sir Ian Anstruther is immortalised as the groom on The White Horse Inn sign in recognition for saving the pub from closure in 1972. In 2017, the current owners – local to Sutton for over 20 years - stepped in to restore the fabric of the 18th century building and the viability of the business ensuring its place as a focal point for the village and neighbouring communities of Barlavington, Bignor, Coates and West Burton for years to come.

The recent restoration of the pub, designed entirely by Odile Griffith, involved the commissioning of local craftsmen and landscaping to ensure the historic features and charm of The White Horse Inn are preserved and protected as part of the contemporary pub and accommodation. The calibre of the renovation was recognised with a Sussex Heritage Trust Award in 2019.